Sunday, December 23, 2012

An Open Letter to Miss Carly Rose Sonenclar


 
My God! Young Lady, but weren’t you ripped off!?  The Producers arranged it so that the Popular Music Vote would be split so that the strong Minority Vote of the Southern Block could walk off with the Win with far less than 50% of the Vote.  In any Civilized Venue, you would have deserved a runoff, no?  Head to head Mr. Steven could never have come even close to beating you.

 

Well, anyway, the reality of it would have been that you would have won next to nothing.  The “5 Million dollar Record Deal” would have been the X-factor Producers shoving money from one of their pockets to another one of their pockets; from left hand into right, but behind their back.   They would have consigned you into cutting a cheezy record with low production values, on a tight schedule, and consisting of mostly horrible generic pop originals.  They would have you made you the pop girl of the season, and then, disillusioned and disappointed, your adoring fans would remember only that you had once been good.   

 

As it stands now, you can get your Own Deal, and under much better contractual considerations.  Oh, you are just 13 years old, and so it might be likely you would still be thinking of High School and College… but not necessarily.  You could home school your way through knowing anything a High School student must know to do well on the SAT Tests, and then  you can enter College whenever your career reaches some natural point of relaxation.

 

Now for some advice… from an old man, and so humor me.   Yes, yes, yes, you have a Once in a Generation Voice, but what is the most important thing now, is not your Voice, but your Taste and Discernment.   Essentially it comes down to whether or not you know what a Hit is.  Some people with amazing degrees of musical talent simply throw it all away by making horrible choices regarding what they choose to record.   For instance, Barbara Streisand, an undeniably talented Lady, now takes up nearly all of her time trying to impress a New York Theatrical Elite that doesn’t do good popular music because, well, they don’t need to… they have a huge captive audience – all those New York Gay People, God Bless them,  that have nowhere else to go.  They go to the same theatres to see the same shows, however horrible they are, satisfied to just to preen like birds out in the theatre lobbies during the intermissions.  But Barbara does this ‘Show’ music hoping to make friends or keep them among this tired sick and wasted ‘elite’.  Meanwhile dumpsters nationwide are brim full of Streisand CD’s, or people are warned off of buying them in the first place.    Joan Osborne did a CD of some of her favorite Blues Songs… songs that had been her inspiration.  My God!, but what a yawn fest!  Macy Grey did a tribute to Stevie Wonder, of mostly songs that Stevie couldn’t  even get into the Top 40, and she tore up the few good songs so badly that, well, we are topping off the Nation’s dumpsters again.  Oh, and there are the Generic Pop Songs.   The Record Companies, who knows why, but they blindly and stupidly demand of Artists that they provide so many original recordings on some fixed schedule.  In a World where anybody who really does write three real honest-to-god Hits in their entire lifetime should be recognized as something of a Mortal God, well the Record Companies  want to fill up records year after year, but with what.  It is a huge waste of plastic!  Even the Best singer song writers are reduced to putting out CD’s full of ‘filler’… sometimes ‘filler’ from start to finish.  Aimee Mann… I used to worship her.  But her most recent CD… I listened to it and cried.  Ten songs and nothing there.

 

The best anecdote I have regarding this particular problem, of record companies demanding ‘filler’ songs on the off chance that one might somehow go against all the odds of market logic and creative judgment to become a surprise hit, is all about a once young star,  Jackie De Shannon.  She had made a hit of a Burt Bacharach song, “What the World Needs Now is Love”, and then she got a big break of being able to open for the Beatles on their 1965 American Tour.  Around about then she thought up her own ‘Hit’ song and had the good sense to know it was a ‘hit’. It was “Put a Little Love In Your Heart”.  She was excited for herself and ran off to the Record Company offices and because her demo tape was so sparse, she made all of the horn parts and string parts with her mouth, and accentuated them by waving her hands all about.  The Execs tried to bluff away her optimism but she stood firm – it was a hit – she knew it and they knew it,  and they would have to pay for it!  Well, they did, but the small print in her contract was a B___h.   She would have to follow the Single soon with an album.  She had something like a few weeks to fill the complete album and she knew and everybody knew it was awful… except the American Public who hadn’t been warned and were very disappointed in her ‘rip off’ album and never forgave her for it.  Remember ,this was during the Age of the Beatles where almost every ‘good’ album had well more than three songs that were actually up in the ‘Hit’ caliber and most of the rest fine enough to listen too without rendering offense or absolute boredom.  So the idea of a complete album with just one good song, when everyone already owned it as a Single, well… it was all bitterness and darkness after that.  And so it is that the way she negotiated an honest-to-god ‘hit’ came down to ruining her career.   Her friend at the time was a young songwriter named Carole King, to whom she poured out all her various laments and warnings.  Carole took them to heart and so when she in turn went off to the Record Companies, she had a complete album full of nearly perfect ‘hits’, from start to finish.  Of course, Carole King, except for a few good songs in later years, was never even nearly able to equal the likes of “Tapestry” again… well, in fact, has anybody?  Most Greatest Hits albums aren’t nearly as good as just plain “Tapestry”.

 

So, the point there is to be very careful in assembling your Work, your CD’s.  Now, of course you can’t please everybody – not everybody likes every song, but we are not talking about that.  We are talking about songs that everybody with a modicum of taste knows to be simply a ‘filler’.  Remember, YOU are the talent.  Remember, that when a Record company Exec gives you advice, well, politely nod your head ‘yes, yes, sure, sure’ but then, go off to the company archives and find out how well this particular exec’s judgments have gone.  Had he been responsible for a series of flat and stupid CD’s, and a broken trail of used up and abandoned artists?  Yes!?  Well, guess what he wants to do to you… not out of hate or malice, but simply because he a stupid business man… probably got the job because he’s somebody’s son-in-law, and not because he even pretends to do anything besides go through the motions of being a Record Company Exec.  So trust your own judgment, but that also means trusting a Producer or somebody that actually does have a Stellar record of producing hit after hit after hit, and never leaving a wounded or melancholy Artist behind.  For instance, Stevie Nick’s Greatest Hits  record jacket is really funny, in that it points out time and again how she moaned and complained that songs her producer wanted her to do simply ‘sucked’ but that he wouldn’t budge and when she finally did them that they ended up being Monster Hits for her.  So, you need to have the Discernment to know who to listen to.  You need both good Judgment of Music and Good Judgment of the people you work with.

 

Oh, and now a personal observation.  You have focused on singing. When it comes to dance and moving on stage, well, it is as though your slippers are made of steel and concrete.  My advice here is to learn quickly how to Visually represent music.  The best method for that is one I have seen in the Far East – Korean Girls come out on stage with sticks that have attached to them these very long flowing ribbons that they twirl and bullwhip around in perfect time to the music.  High notes are whipped up into the air, and the low notes beat along the stage floor.  The audience sees a perfect Visual Translation of the music.  Dance is supposed to do the same thing, but the Medium of arms and legs is not nearly was Wonderful as the sticks and ribbons.   But after one ‘gets’ the idea, then one can translate the Music visually with dance.  And once you can dance, then you can control the stage better.  Oh, and as Rod Stewart or Annie Lennox can attest, being able to toss the mike stand up into the air and catch it like a baton, well, audiences wouldn’t be more amazed unless it were by the 2nd coming of Christ… and if He had good sense, He would learn to toss the mike stand too.   Oh, be careful, and use both hands.    

 

Also, an appreciation for visual motion and dance gives one an idea for the exuberance of some music.  Right now you focus on the Sublimity of Music – those magical moments of a culminating melodic phrase against a background of folded together and consummated harmonies… it does carry one away.  But Music also can have Exuberance and Flight… anywhere from a tickling lightness to an absolute kind of stomp.  Yes, there are thousands of examples of this done badly.  But how often is Musical Sublimity done badly also?   So, yes, you already have the proven ability to take your audience up into the very Stratosphere of musical rapture, but now you need to be able to whip them up into a Frenzy.  You know what they say about Show Business, don’t you?  “Make them Laugh and make them Cry”.  Well, that phrase may apply more so to the Dramatic Arts, but you get the idea.  You need more Range in your Act.  Move them to tears, but also just plain move them.   Get those feet a-tappin.

 

Now, what do you do?  As I said before, anybody who can even write three hits in a lifetime is a veritable God, so I can’t ask you to be a ‘singer-songwriter’, as it is, well, an impossible trade to maintain for very long.  Even Neil Diamond does covers now.  You could find a good Song Writer.  There is a guy in the U.K. that writes for Amy Belle, a very talented young lady that Rod Stewart ‘discovered’ some years back.  The songwriters name is Lindop.  Rod Stewart had brought her out on stage for a concert that went to DVD, and then everyone waited years, and nothing was heard from her, and when the world was ready to simply shrug and forget her, out comes this precious little CD called, ironically enough, “Lost in the Shortcut”.   All of the best songs are by this Lindop character.  See if you can steal him… well, if he still has anything left.

 

But you can always reach back and do covers.  I know you listen to a lot a music… the note ‘bend’ you do at the end of “Feeling Good”, well, Nina doesn’t do that, but the background singers on Donna Summer’s “Hot Stuff”, they do a note bend just like the one you did.  So you listen a lot of music and you don’t hesitate to use what you know.  So go back and get some of these old songs and fix them up… update them.  If you need any ideas, well, I have over 600 ‘favorite’ songs catalogued by Key.  There are some really good songs… songs that had even been ‘hits’… that no one does today.  Yes, and there are probably many good songs out there in Musical History hidden by horrible production choices – good songs made bad.  Oh, James Taylor had first been signed by the Beatle’s Apple Records, and they made “Carolina” sound like a march song, with trombones and tubas.  Oh, and remember how Joe Cocker was able to make the stupid  Ringo Starr song “With a Little Help from my Friends” into a true rock and roll Classic.   You know, nearly all of the ‘Hit’ songs of the Sixties, or well before about 1972 or 74, were done to some awkward time signature… I remember as a juggler having to do everything to a 3 ball pattern, which was not very ‘dancy’, but then songs went ‘even’ somehow and I was able to do 4 ball and the dancing got more fluid .  So I suspect one could go back to the sixties and re-build melodic phrases to a more modern time signature.    

 

Oh, here as an idea, considering your age.  Laura Nero.  Of course you know her, but for my other readers, allow me to elaborate, Laura Nero was, much like our very own Carly Rose, a teenage prodigy.  Some of her songs are almost embarrassingly ‘young’.  “Let’s go down to the River and drink my daddy’s wine, get Blasted”… it’s about a teenager’s first drunk experience.  “Wedding Bell Blues” is a 16 year old girl fantasizing about marriage… almost a child playing ‘house’.  “Stone Soul Picnic”, well… we can guess what that is about.   Barbara Streisand covered Nero.  Oh, and a lady with perhaps the best popular voice of the 20th Century, though nobody gives her the credit for it, Marilyn Macoo, with her Fifth Dimension group, they made a fortune of covering Laura Nero.  But at your age, Laura Nero should be yours… you should do Laura Nero and simply resonate with all that Teenage Prodigy energy.   Oh, and rock and roll.  Cover The Who… do that song about Teenage Wasteland with the best electric violin solo in rock and roll history.

 

Oh, perhaps we dismissed your writing your own material much too soon.  Do write.  But don’t compose on guitar.  People who compose on guitar do so with the most predictable of chords and it all ends up sounding the same…  yes, perfectly constructed songs, but one simply can’t tell them apart.   It is all like Taylor Swift – the songs all seem okay one by one but when the CD is over, the mind has nothing particular to remember because all the songs merge into one big bland mass of sameness.   So compose on keyboard.  Yes, yes, you already play piano, but I recommend going to electronic keyboard so you can transpose all of your notes down to just the white keys, like you are playing everything in the Key of C.  That way you can keep the same key finger patterns and use the transpose key to change Key to fit your vocal range.  This allows you to put all of your work into finding phrases and less into fighting the mechanics of the traditional piano keyboard – two rows of keys, blacks and white, a certain stumbling block, but we all insist on lugging it about to appease the Gods of Holy Musical Tradition .

 

Oh, about musical themes and lyrics.  Well, you are so young.  We are all so used to your Sublimity, that we would be rather disappointed if we only had songs of ‘puppy love’ and passing notes in class.  But if you got too heavy, well, nobody would believe it.  Now, I do not think many people have ever done this, but you are young enough so that we can likely suspect that the Best Literature and Poetry of the English Language is still in front of you.  When High School curriculum requires you to read the Very Best, well, let it ‘kill two birds with one stone, and see if it could perhaps give you some musical or thematic ideas.  And when your interviewers ask about how a 14 year old or a 15 year old can come up with such themes, well, you can plausibly blame it upon Literary Influences.  Oh, and it would prove you are not such a dunce as Taylor Swift.  How can any ‘intelligent’ young lady be exposed to so much fine literature and come out totally unmarked by any of it?

 
Anyway, enough from an Old Man.  If I can be of any further assistance, then, please, just let me know.

No comments: